All Blacks Watch – Forwards

All Blacks - Richie McCaw

Richie McCaw made his first start of the season for the Crusaders last weekend. (c) Geoff Trotter.

New Zealand have named a 35-man training squad ahead of June’s three-test series with Ireland. The omissions of Robbie Fruean and Andre Taylor are particularly surprising for fans of Super Rugby, as those two have been in spectacular form. The injury to Richard Kahui last weekend may mean a late call-up for one of them. Several of the other young players highlighted in last week’s look at the backline options for New Zealand were also left out, but there’s 11 new players included.

So, following on from last week’s look at the backs, let’s check out the form of the forwards Steve Hansen has selected in his training squad. Some of these guys will miss out when the All Blacks management cut the squad to 30 on the 3rd of June. There are some tough decisions to be made.

World Cup-winning loosehead prop Tony Woodcock returns despite the Blues awful season. The 31-year-old has actually been one of the few positives at Eden Park after taking an extended off-season. He has been a force at scrum-time, although niggly injuries have limited him to just 5 starts so far this season. Hansen will be hoping that Woodcock can steer clear of further problems as the crucial months of the season approach. When fit, Woodcock is one of the world’s premier looseheads.

Mils Muliaina, Stephen Donald & Ben Franks

Ben Franks (right) can prop on both sides of the scrum. (c) Geof Wilson.

Behind Woodcock in the loosehead depth chart are Wyatt Crockett and Ben Franks. Crockett has been in solid form for the Crusaders again this season. The 29-year-old is unlucky to be around at the same time as Woodcock, meaning he has been restricted to just a handful of All Blacks caps. His fellow Crusader Franks is an asset to any squad with his ability to play both sides of the scrum. That versatility can also count against him in that it makes him so suitable for the bench, where he is likely to start from against Ireland.

Hansen has selected only two hookers in the 35-man squad, both of them over 30 years of age. Kevin Mealamu is now 33 and if truth be told, his form for the Blues suggests that age is finally catching up with him. He has had a recurring calf injury recently and that hasn’t helped his level of performance. Andrew Hore is likely to start in the middle of the front-row. Despite being the same age as Mealamu, Hore has started all but one game for the Highlanders, getting around the park well.

At tighthead, World Cup Final starter, and brother of Ben, Owen Franks has done enough to retain his position. The 24-year-old has been part of the dominant Crusaders front-row  alongside his brother and Crockett. Competition at tighthead was to come in the shape of Charlie Faumuina and the gigantic Ben Tameifuna. 25-year-old Faumuina has been part of a good Blues scrum and was set for his first cap. Cruelly, a calf tear has ruled him out of this summer’s test series.

Jerome Kaino, Cory Jane & Owen Franks

Owen Franks (right) is likely to start at tighthead. (c) Geof Wilson.

20-year-old Tameifuna represented NZ at the Junior World Championship just last summer and wasn’t expecting much Super Rugby action this season at the Chiefs. But injuries to Ben Afeaki and Toby Smith gave the 138kg prop a chance which he has eagerly taken. He’s started 10 games already as the Chiefs have risen to 2nd in the table. It’s not only his sheer size and strength which have impressed, but also his skillful contributions around the park. Apparently he used to play outhalf back in his school days. He’s definitely one to keep an eye on, particularly as some New Zealanders reckon he could cover hooker too.

In the second-row, Sam Whitelock and Ali Williams return after their involvement in the World Cup last year. Whitelock is still only 23, and having started the World Cup final and shown up well for the Crusaders this season, he will be confident of his starting position. Williams is lucky to be in the squad at all. The 31-year-old has been poor all season for the Blues. However, his experience at international level means he is retained. Hansen will hope Williams’ influence on rookies Luke Romano and Brodie Retallick is positive.

Crusaders man Romano is something of a late developer, getting his first call-up at the age of 26. He started this season on the bench for his club side, but swiftly beat off the challenge of Tom Donnelly to make himself a starter alongside Whitelock. Romano made giant leaps under Rob Penney for the Canterbury ITM Cup side in recent seasons. The new Munster coach said that Romano has the ability to be a Brad Thorn-like figure for the All Blacks.


20-year-old Retallick is an absolute certainty to represent the All Blacks sooner rather than later. The Chiefs man is in his first season of Super Rugby having won the U20 World Cup alongside Tameifuna last year. Retallick’s sheer size is frightening. Standing 6’8″, he has actually had to shed bulk recently, dropping down to 120kg in order to increase his lineout ability. In a recent fitness test, Retallick beat Brad Thorn’s long-standing beep test record for second-rows (he scored 19.3 for those interested!). This is a machine of a young man, destined for test rugby.

So to the back-row. Of the trio that started the World Cup Final, Richie McCaw and Kieran Read are back. Not much needs to be said about that pair. McCaw has recovered from a foot injury and made his first start of the season in the Crusaders loss to the Reds last weekend. Read has captained the Crusaders with distinction in McCaw’s absence and is a world-class operator at No.8. World Cup blindside flanker Jerome Kaino has moved on to Japan, so his All Blacks career is over for now.

The outstanding candidate to replace him is the Highlanders’ Adam Thomson. The 30-year-old has been in superb form, excelling in each of his 10 starts so far this season. He has carried with aggression, impressed in the lineout and scored 4 tries. He deserves his chance. Victor Vito, who has been playing at No.8 for the Hurricanes appears to be Thomson’s main competitor. 25-year-old Vito has the advantage of youth on his side, and has looked physically stronger this season.

All Blacks - Adam Thomson

Adam Thomson deserves to start in the No.6 jersey. (c) Geoff Trotter.

Vito’s fellow Hurricane, Brad Shields, is the third option at blindside in the squad. The 20-year-old was another of last season’s World Junior Championship winners. Shields has made 8 appearances for the Hurricanes this year, but only 1 of them was a start. At 6’4″ and 112kg, Shields is another young player earmarked for a lengthy international career, although this summer’s test series may come a bit too soon for him.

There were two more rookies called-up in the back-row. Sam Cane is yet another of last year’s Junior World Championship-winning side. The 20-year-old openside flanker has continued his impressive form this year with 11 appearances for the Chiefs, 4 of them starts. His potential clearly marks him out as McCaw’s long-term successor at No.7. With McCaw still on the recovery path, Hansen may be tempted to expose Cane to the international game this summer.

Luke Whitelock is the younger brother of second-row Sam, and his teammate at the Crusaders. The 21-year-old was captain of the U20 All Blacks last year, forming an incredibly talented back-row with Cane and Shields. Whitelock can play at 8 or 6, but the fact that he has made just 2 Super Rugby starts this season makes him a surprise call-up, particularly with the omission of Liam Messam. Again, the impression is that Hansen simply wants to integrate Whitelock into the All Blacks set-up as soon as possible.


It’s unlikely that the All Blacks coach will opt for too much youth up front, especially in the first test. I’d predict a starting pack of: 1 – Woodcock, 2 – Hore, 3 – Owen Franks, 4 – Romano, 5 – Sam Whitelock, 6 – Thomson, 7 – McCaw, 8 – Read. The likes of Cane, Retallick, Tameifuna and Shields will be desperately hoping for first caps from the bench. Again, the major point here is that the All Blacks have plenty of competition for places, with so many players in good form. Ireland will have to be at their very best to compete.


Photos courtesy: Geoff Trotter, Geof Wilson.

11 responses to “All Blacks Watch – Forwards

  1. Crockett is an interesting one – can remember that match against Italy in 2009 when he got pinged all day in the scrum and then defended by Paddy O’Brien afterwards. The Aussies comms team suggested that there was questions marks over the legality of his scrum last week but they are obviously not the most impartial of sources…

    Was surprised not to see Messam there, always impressive for the Chiefs and can probably cover a few positions. Agree that it will probably be the same old faces when he announces the Test team too.

  2. Glad to hear there are some doubts over the All Blacks’s props too! Haven’t seen too much of Crockett myself, but with Woodcock having loosehead locked down for a number of years, it’s hard for him to get a run at international level. With Ben Franks covering there off the bench, it appears Crockett will only be involved if Woodcock is injured.

    Agree about Messam being consistently impressive for the Chiefs, don’t know if Hansen simply doesn’t rate him or what. He said that he “knows what Messam can do” so that’s why why wasn’t called up at this stage. I’m sure Messam would rather be in the squad showing his value though. I reckon it would be good for Ireland if Hansen bloods a few of the younger guys but just don’t see it happening, especially for the first test. He won’y want to risk starting on a losing note!

  3. Retallick is unreal, a mutant. I’ve really enjoyed watching the Chiefs this year for their forward play as much as their back play – club captain Clarke has been excellent in the second row, but Retallick outstrips him. He does so many things well for a 20-year old – carries well, handles, great body position at ruck-time …

    Himself and Eben Etzebeth of the Stormers will be knocking corners off each other for the next decade of Super Rugby/Tri-Nations.

  4. Agreed – the Retallick vs Etzebeth clashes and also Gill vs Hooper for the Aussies should be cracking longterm rivalries.

    Some great work recently on your blogs fellas – look forward to your HCup Final views! – Russ

  5. That battle is going to be incredible over the next decade. Mole, the succinct description of ‘mutant’ could equally apply to Etzebeth. What are these guys on? Size, maturity and skills all hard to believe for their age! An Irish second-row could only dream of having to lose mass at the age of 20.

    Cheers Russ, appreciate the kind words. Will be doing stuff later in the week, can’t wait for Saturday! Should be another brilliant game.

  6. Just read on Munsterfans that both Dave Foley and Ian Nagle require/have had shoulder surgery and will be out of action for three months. Those guys are 23/24 and are considered young for second rows in Ireland [and they’re both good players], but they’re way, way off the pace when it comes to physical development compared to their southern hemisphere counterparts.

  7. alastair byrne

    Good stuff murray..sometimes i miss the european games as i work u record and show all irish provincial teams at rabo, heineken and international level? And how long afterwards do you put them on site?
    it was a terrific win for the men in blue. Brad Thorn is a legend and a monster of a man.But BOD with his popping stitches did us proud once more.However these Nz ers are a different kettle of fish. They can do to us what Wales have been doing our midfield and create one on v boys.I am hoping for one test win..we have the guys but whether we have the guile and the committment , time will tell. I believe alot depends on POC .If he plays we have our Brad Thorn . If he doesnt i worry. Got my tickets to game in Christchurch..cant bloody wait..

    • Thanks Alistair! Unfortunately I don’t have the equipment to record and post all the matches. I do try to post up any highlights I can find on Youtube, usually the Monday after the weekend’s games. The Heineken Cup final in full is here if you wanna watch it again –

      Brad Thorn had increased his legend massively over here in the past few months. Running out of superlatives. You’re right about the NZ ers, they’re on a different level. The best we can hope for is sneaking one win, but even that would be a huge ask. Beating New Zealand would be one of our best ever results! I reckon POC will play, I just don’t think he’s going to miss this. I have a great feeling about BOD too, he wants this win more than anything else now. His last chance to beat the All Blacks. Jealous you got tickets and are going to be at one of the games, should be brilliant! Do you keep an eye on the Super Rugby? NZ teams are going well, and so much young talent coming through, scary!

      • alastair byrne

        certainly rugby channel so watch the above mentioned.. i always see the games but delayed if on night shift.. Got one for you…not everyone will like it but what about this team if POC isnt wont happen as it would have to be trialled first .Here we go…healy, best and ross, ferris and toner second row, mclaughlin, heaslip and o brien back row…Tuohy and Ryan on bench…not everyone will be happy especially munster men but i for one would like to see it….mister cleary..5 props and 3 loosies doesnt do it for me but keep dreamin!

      • Nice one, you’re covered for all the games so! That’s a really interesting selection, definitely think Toner is unlucky not to have been named in the squad, but if POC doesn’t go then he’ll be in. I’d go for Tuohy to start in the second-row. He’s been excellent all season for Ulster. Ferris in the second-row is an interesting one. Have heard it mentioned a few times and it would give out pack so much more mobility. With Toner in there, the lineout would still be in good shape. But playing second-row is quite different to the back-row, especially at international level. It might mean less involvement in the loose for Ferris. Also at scrum-time, it would affect Ireland’s solidity there.

        But an interesting pack definitely. McLaughlin can’t do anything more to earn international recognition. He’s excellent for Leinster in everything he does. Kidney seems to think he’s not quite up to it at international level though. Another coach might think differently. What’s the general feeling about Ireland down in New Zealand? Surely they’re very confident of winning all three tests? Do they rate Ireland’s players at all? Would be interesting to get their opinions!

      • alastair byrne

        In general, they think we are cannon fodder! However, we have a programme called northern exposure, where they review the northen hemisphere rugby weekly.These guys know about europe(guys like justin marshall)..they know what to expect. They are extremely knowledgeable loving both Leinster and Munster having a new admiration for ulster. They do think we have world class players…they love Kearney, POC , SOB, JH, ZEBO ..the list goes on..they also think zebo should have been playing during 6 nations..but, they think that club success is not being translated into international success, and that something is askew in this department.On one final note..they Do appreciate BOD..they see him as the epitome of success..a leader and a defender…i would love to see him skin some of those all blacks….love it!(rempants of Kev Keegan)……

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s